Is SD-WAN the Right Choice for UK Networks? Understand the Benefits, Costs, and Key Considerations

Explore our comprehensive services including Ethernet, FTTP, Managed Fibre, SoGea, Mobile Data/IoT, Business Broadband, SD-WAN and MPLS

Introduction: Understanding the Need for SD-WAN

With the rapid adoption of cloud technology, many businesses are evaluating their networking options, specifically SD-WAN (Software-Defined Wide Area Networking). SD-WAN is often recommended for its promise of flexibility, lower costs, and enhanced network performance. However, is SD-WAN the right choice for UK-based networks, or are there alternatives that might better meet local business needs?

This article breaks down SD-WAN’s benefits and limitations, particularly for UK networks, where specific conditions could impact performance. Read on to explore whether SD-WAN or a traditional MPLS (Multiprotocol Label Switching) network is the best option for your business.

Why SD-WAN Was Developed

The rise of cloud-based software and remote work has shifted network demands from legacy MPLS setups to more dynamic, cloud-friendly solutions. SD-WAN was developed to allow businesses to connect branch offices and remote workers to cloud resources using standard internet connections, rather than relying exclusively on costly, rigid MPLS circuits.

However, MPLS remains a popular choice for its stability and reliability, particularly for companies needing predictable, secure connectivity for local networks. Understanding why SD-WAN emerged can help in determining whether it's ideal for a UK-based business environment.

UK Networks and the Unique Considerations for SD-WAN

While SD-WAN is marketed as a global solution, UK businesses should consider specific network factors before making a decision. Unlike larger countries with widespread SD-WAN Points of Presence (PoPs), the UK’s compact geography may offer limited routing benefits from SD-WAN. Many SD-WAN solutions are optimized for long-distance traffic, but within the UK, the difference in performance between SD-WAN and MPLS may not be as noticeable.

In particular, UK-based businesses with branch offices primarily within the country might not see the cost or performance advantages SD-WAN provides for companies with global footprints. Therefore, businesses focused on intra-UK networking should carefully evaluate their real-world performance needs before fully embracing SD-WAN.

Evaluating the Cost of SD-WAN in the UK

Cost is one of the biggest factors driving interest in SD-WAN. While MPLS networks are typically more expensive due to dedicated infrastructure, SD-WAN claims to reduce costs by allowing businesses to use standard broadband for WAN connectivity. However, upfront and ongoing costs can vary widely.

Initial Hardware Costs: SD-WAN requires investment in specialized routers and potentially additional equipment to maintain redundancy.
Ongoing Subscription Fees: Most SD-WAN solutions are subscription-based, which can add to operational costs.
Hidden Costs: Implementation, management, and potential security services add to the total expenditure.

For UK-only operations, MPLS’s additional stability may be worth the cost compared to the potential complexities and hidden fees associated with SD-WAN.

Benefits of SD-WAN for Some Organisations

Although SD-WAN may not be universally beneficial, it can offer distinct advantages for certain types of organisations:

Enhanced Cloud Performance: SD-WAN is often ideal for businesses heavily reliant on cloud services, as it prioritizes critical applications and provides direct-to-cloud connections that can bypass centralised data centers.
Greater Network Control and Monitoring: SD-WAN platforms generally include dashboards that offer real-time insights into traffic flow, which can be invaluable for companies that need to monitor and optimize performance frequently.

For businesses that prioritise cloud access and application control, SD-WAN may offer significant value.

Challenges and Limitations of SD-WAN

While SD-WAN has its benefits, it also presents potential challenges:

Increased Complexity: Implementing and managing an SD-WAN network can be more complex than MPLS, which is largely managed by the service provider.
Security Risks: SD-WAN often relies on internet connections, which can expose the network to security threats if not properly managed. Businesses may need to invest in additional security solutions.
Unpredictable Performance: For UK-only businesses, SD-WAN may not offer a consistent performance advantage over MPLS, especially when factoring in potential routing inefficiencies.

Is SD-WAN Right for Your Business?

The decision to adopt SD-WAN or remain with MPLS depends on your organisation’s unique requirements. For businesses heavily invested in cloud technology or managing a hybrid workforce, SD-WAN’s flexibility may be beneficial. However, UK-based businesses that operate primarily within the country might find MPLS more suited to their needs.

Here are key considerations:

Cloud Reliance: If your business relies extensively on cloud applications, SD-WAN could enhance performance.
Network Control Needs: SD-WAN may be preferable if you need granular control over your network traffic.
Budget: For businesses on a strict budget, carefully weigh SD-WAN’s hidden costs before committing.

For complex decisions, working with experts like Supplier Synergy can streamline the process, helping you select the best networking solution.

Conclusion

SD-WAN has changed the landscape of enterprise networking, offering flexibility and cloud-centric capabilities. However, for UK-only networks, the value proposition may not always hold, especially when compared to the stable and predictable performance of MPLS. With careful consideration of your organisation's cloud usage, budget, and performance needs, you can make an informed decision about whether SD-WAN is the best fit.

Contact Supplier Synergy for expert guidance in choosing the ideal network for your unique business requirements.

Why Choose Supplier Synergy?

Supplier Synergy redefines access to connectivity. We offer one provider, one process, one invoice, and one support team, regardless of the service, technology, or carrier you select.

Our platform gives you instant access to a catalogue of technically vetted connectivity products and services, guaranteeing the best price, best features, widest choice, and simplified ordering.

Supplier Synergy Services

Ethernet- Leased Line
Experience dedicated, ultra-reliable, fully managed connectivity with speeds of up to 10GB.
FTTP
Achieve full fibre speeds with advanced solutions up to 2.5GB.
Managed Fibre
Enjoy a fully managed 100Mb service designed for SMEs.
SoGea
Simplify broadband delivery with a streamlined service.
Mobile Data/IoT
Empower your operations with enterprise-grade mobile data and IoT solutions.
Business Broadband
Fast, secure ADSL2+ & FTTC broadband, tailored specifically for businesses.
SD-WAN
Future-proof your network with modern, secure intelligent WAN solutions.
MPLS
Enhance network efficiency with secure, scalable technology.